Needs to be decided.
Acid: Just going to fail him outright. Spent most of his trial inactive and doesn't really do enough when he is active.
I11egal: He's okay on a personal level, but to be blunt he's clueless and seems a bit braindead. There's been some improvement, sure. But I'm a no. "He's improved" or "he's willing to learn" isn't cutting it for me. End of the day should be judging this on if he's fit for the job now, not the hypothetical future.. I don't think he is. Would look bad declining both of them but meh. I'll let you decide.
Acid Range: Failed